Permanence & Definition

Investors have paired bonds with stocks for balance forever. The old rule of thumb was simple: when stocks fall, bonds rise…or at least don’t fall. That rule hasn’t held up for a while now. In our view comparing the day-to-day price moves misses what makes bonds valuable in the first place.

When you buy a bond and hold it until it matures, you know exactly what you’ll get: regular interest payments and the bond’s face value back on a set date. Prices will move up and down along the way as interest rates change, but if the borrower doesn’t default, the bond pays what it promised. We call this permanence and definition, and it’s the main reason to own bonds in our opinion.

Most investors don’t own individual bonds. They own mutual funds and ETFs that pool money to hold thousands of bonds at a time. That offers convenience and broad diversification, but it gives up something important. When interest rates rise, bond prices fall, and many fund investors sell – exactly what we’re seeing now. To pay those investors back, the fund often has to sell bonds at those lower prices and lock in losses. These bonds never reach maturity for the original investor, so the promise of getting that reliable stream of cash flows is gone. The reverse can happen too – when rates fall, rising prices turn forced selling into gains. Either way, the outcome is driven by other investors’ behavior and the fund’s management of that behavior – not on what the bond promised.

Thanks to a call from a young client (we get our best signals from clients!) last week and the ensuing smart conversation, we think it makes increasing sense as people focus on reducing portfolio risk to pull away from bond funds in favor of actual bonds. We focus on highly-rated bonds with shorter maturities, which have historically had a very low risk of default, spread across dozens of issuers. In moving towards bonds, we’re getting both diversification to help manage risk, and the permanence and definition that makes bonds worth owning. If you have questions about how this might affect you, please reach out – we’re always happy to talk it through!